Sign In


Send Message

Send Message

RareWaters's Listings


  • John Urbanowicz October 4, 2020

    Big fun! Good sized fish for such a small creek! Many 14” fish. Setting is beautiful. Owner was very friendly.

  • Fred Frazzini October 4, 2020

    We enjoyed a long successful day on this property. Greeted by very friendly owner, who explained the really easy access. We were able to stay on property to eat lunch off the back of our vehicle. No mention of restroom facilities and we did not ask or impose. Water was perfect, weather a bit warm, but we both caught fish.

  • Jeremiah Puckett October 2, 2020

    Great stretch of water. Flows were a little low the day I was there but was able to get into a couple brownies. Property has well marked boundaries with map included! Fish came on small nymphs in the slower pools.

  • EVAN ESCHMEYER September 18, 2020

    Fantastic fishing in a stunning location. Steady hookups with wild fish all day. Can't wait to go back.

  • David
    David September 15, 2020

    The Hartsel property was easy to find, it's a beautiful stretch of the Middle Fork South Platte River. Fishing was good. Caught 6, and lost a few too. All browns, but one of the largest that broke off was a large bow. Most everything on hoppers, a small brown took a tungsten wire nymph, and I had two bumps on a black sex dungeon but no full take. The river is quite shallow now, and at very low flow. I avoided fishing a few pools where current was low, water was warm and trout appeared stressed. We need water flows to pick back up soon. I’m sure the property will be exceptional at higher flow levels, and looking forward to heading back in the spring.